- Published on
When considering buying a landed property in Singapore, it's essential for buyers to be aware of the potential for compulsory land acquisition.
Land in Singapore is a scarce commodity that is very limited in supply making our land a very precious possession and ownership rights are sacrosanct. Notwithstanding this, there will be a need from time to time to acquire land from private landowners to achieve a wider public good, mainly for public development. In aspiring to a higher level of land development, Singapore has developed some form of expropriation laws to achieve national objectives, which is manifested in the Land Acquisition Act.
The Land Acquisition Act empowers the government to acquire land for public purposes and it outlines the rights of landowners and the process of acquisition where the government has the authority to acquire private land for public purposes or development projects, such as infrastructure, public housing, or urban redevelopment. The Land Acquisition Act ensures that landowners are compensated fairly, but the compensation may not always reflect the full market value, as it is based on statutory valuation guidelines.
"The compensatory framework in the Act is often a major point of contention, in that the landowners feel inadequately compensated for the acquisition of their land." said real estate consultant Kiwi Lim.
The Land Acquisition Act sets out the procedures and compensation mechanisms for landowners. Here's what you need to know:
The Acquisition Process
- Prior to acquiring a piece of land for public development, the Government and its respective agencies undergo planning to optimise land use without resorting to land acquisition. Occasionally, planning considerations may inevitably involve land acquisition, which is a last resort.
Risks to Landed Property Owners
- If you're purchasing a landed property, particularly in areas earmarked for redevelopment or new infrastructure projects, there's a risk that your property could be subject to compulsory acquisition.
- While compulsory acquisition is not common, it's a possibility in areas undergoing significant urban renewal or infrastructure expansion.
Compensation
- Landowners are entitled to compensation based on the market value of the property at the date of acquisition. However, this value is determined by government appointed valuers and may differ from private valuations.
- Additional compensation may be provided for other factors, such as loss of business or disturbance, but these are typically subject to strict criteria. The Act sets out the factors for consideration in determining the compensation, which is broadly based on the market value of the land which include but are not limited to: recent sales transactions for the property, other comparable sales transactions, adjustments for condition, size, location, tenure and time difference between transactions, which can influence the valuation.
Mitigating the Risk
- Before purchasing a landed property, especially in areas of potential development, check the Urban Redevelopment Authority’s (URA) Master Plan. This plan outlines land use zoning and possible future developments, which may indicate areas at risk of acquisition.
- Engage a real estate lawyer or consultant to assess the risk and provide advice on the potential for compulsory acquisition based on the property’s location and surrounding developments.
What to Do If Your Property Is Acquired
- If your property is subject to compulsory acquisition, you'll receive a Notice of Acquisition. You have the right to contest the compensation amount through the Appeals Board if you believe it's inadequate.
- Engage a professional valuer or legal advisor to assist with the compensation claim and appeal process, if necessary.
Compulsory acquisition of land is a power vested in the Singapore government to acquire land for a fair market value for public development. In recent years, there has been a recent spike in projects to build and strengthen Singapore’s economic and social infrastructure. Inevitably, some areas of privately-owned land may be involved in the government’s planning considerations. As a last resort, land is compulsorily acquired in the interest of the wider community.
It is noteworthy that while the Singapore government may acquire the Property or part thereof under the Land Acquisition Act (Chapter 152 of the 1985 Revised Edition) and the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act 1995 should Land Transport Authority (LTA) decide to carry out road improvements (in which case, the compensation payable will be based on the market value as at 1st January 1995 or the market value as at the date of the acquisition, whichever is lower), however if the government acquires the land under the Street Works Act, no compensation shall be payable based on section 14 of said act.
"In 2021, the government compulsorily acquired a four-storey building along Thomson Road and the freehold 776-sqm site that it sits on were acquired under the Land Acquisition Act. The building comprised of twelve residential units and four shops which the government will acquire and demolish by the end of the same year for the construction of the North-South Corridor nearby." said Kiwi Lim from Propnex Realty.
"Therefore, if you purchase a land and / or property that is affected by lines of road reserve which is required to be set aside, you run the risk of being uncompensated for the reduction in your land / property area."
- Published on
Yesterday's news reported at least three more home owners, one sub-contractor and a former employee obtaining orders from the Small Claims Tribunals against interior design firm Formal Informal Practice over incomplete renovation projects, overdue payments and unpaid wages.
Over the years, complaints about delays, shady practices, and shoddy workmanship have been a persistent concern in the renovation industry in Singapore. Homeowners often share stories of projects running behind schedule, with costs ballooning beyond initial estimates. These delays can disrupt daily life and cause significant stress, especially when families need to vacate their homes or face extended construction periods.
The issue of shady practices has plagued the home renovation industry in Singapore especially after Covid hit us with tight manpower shortage issues. Some contractors were found engaging in unethical behaviors such as no work done, pro-longed delayed work, hidden fees, misrepresentation of services, or using substandard materials and countless reports were made and the issue raised with the government. Such practices not only undermine trust but also jeopardize the safety and quality of the final outcome. Homeowners have reported instances where contractors disappeared mid-project, leaving them with half-finished work and financial losses.
These issues highlight the importance of due diligence when choosing a contractor, as well as the need for robust consumer protection mechanisms. To safeguard against these common problems, homeowners are encouraged to research thoroughly, check references, and ensure that contracts are clear and comprehensive.
Avoiding a renovation nightmare requires careful planning, thorough research and clear communication. Kiwi Lim who has more than ten years experience in real estate offers some tips to help ensure a smooth and successful renovation project:
1. Plan Thoroughly Before Starting
- Define Your Goals: Clearly outline what you want to achieve with your renovation, including your priorities and non-negotiables.
- Create a Budget: Set a realistic budget that includes a contingency fund for unexpected expenses, typically around 10-20% of the total cost.
- Timeline: Establish a clear timeline for the project, including start and end dates, while being mindful of potential delays.
2. "If its too good to be true, it probably is"
“If you meet someone who says everything (you want) can be done at the lowest cost, very likely something is wrong” says Cat Lim - a homeowner who was 'scammed' by a smooth talking and seemingly friendly contractor- Ah Xiang from UM3 Services Pte. Ltd. (UEN: 202016030D). "Ah Xiang ghosted me after I paid the deposit, even the boss of UM3 Services Pte. Ltd. - Lau Yong Hao did not respond after I tried contacting him and emailed the deposit screenshot as proof of payment to their company. The company is still registered as operational in ACRA."
3. Detailed Contract
- Clear Scope of Work: Ensure the contract includes a detailed description of the work to be done, materials to be used, and the total cost.
- Payment Terms: Agree on payment milestones tied to the completion of specific project phases, rather than a lump sum up front.
- Warranties and Guarantees: Make sure the contract specifies any warranties on materials and workmanship.
4. Choose the Right Contractor
- Research and Recommendations: Seek recommendations from friends, family, or online reviews. Verify the contractor’s credentials, licenses, and insurance.
- Check Past Work: Ask to see examples of previous projects, and if possible, visit completed sites or speak to past clients.
- Get A Few Quotes As Reference: Obtain detailed quotes from several contractors and compare them to ensure you’re getting a fair deal.
5. Communication
- Establish a Point of Contact: Designate a single point of contact for both the homeowner and the contractor to avoid miscommunication.
- Regular Updates: Schedule regular check-ins with the contractor to discuss progress and address any issues promptly.
6. Permits and Regulations
- Understand Local Regulations: Ensure that all necessary permits are obtained before work begins. Non-compliance can lead to fines and project delays.
- Building Codes: Ensure that the renovation adheres to local building codes and safety standards.
7. Quality Control
- Specify Materials: Clearly specify the brands, types, and quality of materials to be used in the project.
- Inspections: Consider hiring an independent inspector to check the quality of work at key stages of the renovation.
8. Prepare for the Unexpected
- Contingency Plan: Have a backup plan in case of unexpected issues, such as supply delays or unforeseen structural / manpower issues.
- Flexibility: Be prepared to make decisions if changes to the plan are necessary, while keeping an eye on the budget.
9. Document Everything
- Keep Records: Maintain a file of all documents, including contracts, receipts, warranties, and correspondence.
- Progress Photos: Take regular photos of the project’s progress for your records.
10. Stick To The Plan
- Stick to the Plan: Avoid making significant changes to the project once it’s underway, as this can lead to increased costs and delays.
11. Trust Your Instincts
- Red Flags: If something feels off or too good to be true, investigate further. Don’t ignore potential warning signs, such as a contractor being vague or pressuring you for immediate payment.
Real estate consultant Kiwi Lim reminds homeowners to practice due diligence, avoid paying large sums upfront and request for renovation instalments to be pegged to deliverables. Doing these could save a lot of heartaches as bringing and enforcing the renovation contractor in the Small Claims Tribunal would require homeowners to spend more time and money on legal fees."
Homeowners have repeatedly appealed to the government to enforce stricter regulations in the renovation industry, as well as implement more effective safeguards and recourse for consumers and sub-contractors that are owed money, e.g., renovation firms could be required to set up escrow accounts for customers’ monies – a practice already in place in industries such as banking and finance.
It's crucial for Singapore's renovation industry to uphold higher standards of professionalism and accountability to ensure that every project meet the expectations and needs of the homeowner / client.
"As Singapore's home renovation industry continues to grow, addressing these challenges is essential to maintaining consumer confidence and ensuring that the dream of home improvement does not turn into a nightmare for Singaporeans." said Kiwi Lim.
